NDLI: Judicial Discretion and the Problem of Dirty Hands

Content Provider	Springer Nature Link
Author	Tigard, Daniel
Copyright Year	2015
Abstract	H.L.A. Hart’s lost and found essay ‘Discretion’ has provided new insight into the issue of how legal systems can cope with indeterminacy in the law. The so-called ‘open texture’ of law calls for the exercise of judicial discretion, which, I argue, renders judges susceptible to the problem of dirty hands. To show this, I frame the problem as being open to an array of appropriate emotional responses, namely, various senses of guilt. With these responses in mind, I revise an example from Michael Walzer’s original analysis in a way that highlights purely personal sacrifices in solutions to dirty hands situations. I then turn to an account of moral emotions in legal decision-making and show how judges—in failing to advance all interests—might be left with a unique sense of guilt. With an application of this account to Hart’s legal positivism, it can be seen that a judge’s hands are often dirtied in resolving borderline cases. If discretion leaves judges in situations where they must do wrong in order to do right, Hart’s endorsement of a closure view of wrongdoing will lead to difficulties in how he can explain the presence of moral remainders in jurisprudence.
Starting Page	177
Ending Page	192
Page Count	16
File Format	PDF
ISSN	13862820
Journal	Ethical Theory and Moral Practice
Volume Number	19
Issue Number	1
e-ISSN	15728447
Language	English
Publisher	Springer Netherlands
Publisher Date	2015-05-19
Publisher Place	Dordrecht
Access Restriction	One Nation One Subscription (ONOS)
Subject Keyword	Discretion Dirty hands Moral emotions H.L.A. Hart Michael Walzer Ethics Political Philosophy Theory of Medicine/Bioethics Philosophy of Medicine Ontology
Content Type	Text
Resource Type	Article
Subject	Philosophy Social Sciences

Sl.	Authority	Responsibilities	Communication Details
1	Ministry of Education (GoI), Department of Higher Education	Sanctioning Authority	https://www.education.gov.in/ict-initiatives
2	Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur	Host Institute of the Project: The host institute of the project is responsible for providing infrastructure support and hosting the project	https://www.iitkgp.ac.in
3	National Digital Library of India Office, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur	The administrative and infrastructural headquarters of the project	Dr. B. Sutradhar bsutra@ndl.gov.in
4	Project PI / Joint PI	Principal Investigator and Joint Principal Investigators of the project	Dr. B. Sutradhar bsutra@ndl.gov.in Prof. Saswat Chakrabarti will be added soon
5	Website/Portal (Helpdesk)	Queries regarding NDLI and its services	support@ndl.gov.in
6	Contents and Copyright Issues	Queries related to content curation and copyright issues	content@ndl.gov.in
7	National Digital Library of India Club (NDLI Club)	Queries related to NDLI Club formation, support, user awareness program, seminar/symposium, collaboration, social media, promotion, and outreach	clubsupport@ndl.gov.in
8	Digital Preservation Centre (DPC)	Assistance with digitizing and archiving copyright-free printed books	dpc@ndl.gov.in
9	IDR Setup or Support	Queries related to establishment and support of Institutional Digital Repository (IDR) and IDR workshops	idr@ndl.gov.in

Punishing ‘Dirty Hands’—Three Justifications

After the Standard Dirty Hands Thesis: Towards a Dynamic Account of Dirty Hands in Politics

Tragic-Remorse–The Anguish of Dirty Hands

‘Learning How Not to Be Good’: Machiavelli and the Standard Dirty Hands Thesis

Conflictual Moralities, Ethical Torture: Revisiting the Problem of “Dirty Hands”

Civilian Immunity, Supreme Emergency, and Moral Disaster

Rejecting Empathy for Animal Ethics

Michael Smith: The Moral Problem

Moral Contextualism and the Problem of Triviality

Judicial Discretion and the Problem of Dirty Hands

Similar Documents

Punishing ‘Dirty Hands’—Three Justifications

After the Standard Dirty Hands Thesis: Towards a Dynamic Account of Dirty Hands in Politics

Tragic-Remorse–The Anguish of Dirty Hands

‘Learning How Not to Be Good’: Machiavelli and the Standard Dirty Hands Thesis

Conflictual Moralities, Ethical Torture: Revisiting the Problem of “Dirty Hands”

Civilian Immunity, Supreme Emergency, and Moral Disaster

Rejecting Empathy for Animal Ethics

Michael Smith: The Moral Problem

Moral Contextualism and the Problem of Triviality

Judicial Discretion and the Problem of Dirty Hands